“But You’re So Good At It.”

The Atlantic Journal | Issue 6 

Have you ever mentioned wanting to shift your career, focus, or energy, only to hear, “But you’re so good at what you do!”? 

It’s meant as a compliment. Someone recognizes what you’ve built and the person they’ve come to rely on. 

But when you’re wondering what comes next- perhaps a new venture, retirement, volunteer or board work, or a different way of spending your time- those words can be surprisingly difficult to hear. 

You may not have a definite plan. Just a feeling that something else deserves your attention. 

I call it “getting itchy.” An internal restlessness comes over me that I can’t quite explain. I recognize the desire to grow, learn something new, or make my current situation more challenging. I just don’t know where that feeling is leading. 

What makes that restlessness confusing is that I can feel it while enjoying- and taking pride in- what I already do. There’s comfort in being capable: knowing the work, understanding the expectations, and recognizing what needs to happen before anyone asks. When I’ve worked hard to reach that point, wondering what else might be possible can feel almost disloyal to my own ambition. 

I wanted this. I worked for this! Why am I questioning it? Shouldn’t I feel grateful? 

Then come the practical questions. What would a change mean for the security, enjoyment, professional reputation, and relationships I’ve built along the way? Part of my hesitation is the fear that pursuing something new could mean leaving those accomplishments behind. 

This is where Beyond, one of The Atlantic Club’s Four Seats, gives me a useful question: How can I care for what I’ve built while making room for what I want next? 

For one woman, that might mean sharing responsibility while pursuing an idea of her own. For another, it means staying involved in her work while creating more time for interests outside it. 

My own answer is still taking shape. I’m learning to give it time while finding a purpose for that persistent drive- and preserving the momentum I’ve already created. Talking it through with someone who listens, asks thoughtful questions, and shares her perspective helps me make sense of what I’m feeling. 

That’s why it matters who is beside us in these conversations. The way we respond to one another can help us understand ourselves and feel more capable of exploring what comes next. 

This connection between relationships and personal growth is central to relational-cultural theory, developed through the work of Jean Baker Miller and her colleagues at Wellesley College’s Stone Center. 

For me, this helps explain why being heard, valued, and able to be myself matters. A woman who listens with curiosity might ask a question I haven’t considered, challenge an assumption, or recognize an ability I’ve overlooked. I can admit uncertainty and leave with a clearer understanding of myself. 

“Why would you give up something you’re already successful at?” leaves me defending a decision I haven’t even made. “What part of this feels most meaningful to you?” gives me room to explore what’s taking shape without presenting a finished plan. 

That is the connection The Atlantic Club offers: access to other women navigating their lives personally and professionally, bringing different experiences, perspectives, and relationships to the table. 

A conversation may lead to a useful introduction, a collaborator, or a new way of seeing a familiar situation. Each woman brings something another may need, alongside questions of her own. 

Access is the product. Reciprocity is the culture. 

So when a woman says, “I know I’m good at it. I’m just wondering what else is possible,” there is room at the table to explore her answer. 

What would you like to explore, even while you’re still good at what you do? 

Further reading: Wellesley Centers for Women, “The Development of Relational-Cultural Theory.” 

Next
Next

A Reaction Piece: Speak Boldly. The Weight We No Longer Have to Carry Alone.